Should Beyonce tell Kelis she’s sampling her song?

In the past 48 hours, the only noise louder than Beyhive’s buzz came from R&B singer Kelis, who was furious that Beyonce auditioned her 1999 song “Get Together With You” without notifying her. The sample appears on the song “Energy” from Beyoncé’s just-released album Renaissance; the officially recognized writers and producers of “Getting With You” are Neptune, aka Pharrell Williams and Chad Hugo, for Kelis’s Most of the early recordings, including her iconic 2003 hit “Milkshake”.

In a long list of Instagram posts, Kelis wrote: “It’s not a collaboration, it’s theft. My thoughts are also appalling because the level of disrespect and total ignorance by all 3 parties is astounding…I’m just like everyone else Heard about it. Everything is not as it seems, some people in this industry have no soul or integrity and they fool everyone.”

There’s a lot to unravel here, professional, personal and macro.

From a legal standpoint, two veteran music business lawyers told type It is possible, but unlikely, that Beyonce’s team is contractually required to notify Kelis of the sample, even if she is a “Get With You” performing artist: she is neither the known author of the work (i.e. Williams and Hugo) nor the copyright holder. Someone (Virgin Records, owned by Universal Music Group). Kelis appeared to admit this in an Instagram video on Friday, where she said Beyonce told her she was auditioning the song should be “human courtesy”, though she added that the situation “really has nothing to do with Beyonce.”

Looking back 23 years, on a personal and professional level, when the song was released in December 1999, both Kelis and Neptunes were in the early stages of their careers: while Williams and Hugo were both in their 20s and a rising star Since the beginning of the songwriter-production team has Ol’ Dirty Bastard, MC Lyte, SWV, Clipse and others, Kelis is only 20 years old. The three were close friends at the time. Kelly has previously said she feels she is not being recognized or compensated for her work with the duo.

She told the Guardian in 2020: “I was told we were going to split the whole thing on 33/33/33, but we didn’t.” Their lawyers, etc.” She said she initially didn’t notice that she wasn’t properly paid for her work on the first two albums, both of which Neptune produced because she made money from touring “and The fact that I’m not poor feels enough,” she said.

“Their argument was: ‘Okay, you signed,'” she continued. “I thought: ‘Yes, I signed what I was told, but I was too young and stupid to double-check it.'”

While she said she hadn’t met Hugo recently, she had met Pharrell at an industry event a few years before the Guardian interview. “He did his infamous thing to me, which was nodding on stage [to someone in the audience], so it seems like mutual respect, and actually, I thought, well, I’m not going to yell, “You stole all my publishing!” So you end up nodding in response, and everyone thinks everything is fine . For example, whatever. “

Williams — who detailed his erroneous end to a publishing deal during his inaugural speech to the Songwriters Hall of Fame last month — has in the past declined to discuss the situation with Kelly, and his rep has not responded. typerequest for comment. Earlier this year, Hugo made a veiled comment on the issue in an interview with Vulture, saying “I’ve heard her say about it. I mean, I don’t deal with that. I usually hire business people to help Deal with that sort of thing. We made some cool records with Kelis back then.”

The macro question — who should be credited and paid for a song, and how much — goes back to the early days of copyright, if not creativity itself. type The issue was explored at length last year in an article titled “Inside the Dirty Business of Hit Songwriting,” which showed that the practice of artists or business people charging credits or royalties for songs they didn’t write dates back to 1950. The chronology and, as depicted in the film 2020’s “Marini’s Black Bottom,” is much longer than that. While some examples were allegedly cut out – Elvis Presley’s manager and countless others demanded a significant portion of a song’s earnings, thinking the money wouldn’t roll in without them – other Humans belong to the greyest area. More than 40 years after the song’s release, Procol Harum organist Matthew Fisher has won songwriting credits and retrospective royalties for the 1967 blockbuster “A Whiteer Shade of Pale,” and countless other cases have been fought in and out of court. Williams found himself losing a songwriting lawsuit in the high-profile “Blurred Lines” case in 2015, when a jury ordered him, Robin Thicke and the song’s publisher to pay Marvin Gaye’s Family paid nearly $5 million to violate late singer’s 1977 work. Hit “must give up,” a decision that was upheld in 2018, although Williams insisted he disagreed.

Kelis has more than a dozen songwriting credits, including her 2006 hit “Bossy,” which was certified double platinum in the United States. However, her claim in Friday’s Instagram post that Williams “never wrote a song, he wrote lyrics every day of his life” was an exaggeration at best: Hugo or not, Williams is a past 30-year-old. One of the most successful songwriter and producer of the year, he has written songs including his own “Happy”, Britney Spears’ “I’m a Slave 4 U”, Beyonce’s “Work It Out” , “Drop It While It’s Hot” by Snoop Dogg, and dozens of other songs.

who is right? Who is wrong? Only the people in the room knew, obviously the memories were different. The result of this situation, all of the above and countless others: make sure the credits and divisions are clear before the song is released, because “humanity” doesn’t hold up in court.

Leave a Comment

%d bloggers like this: